Similarities in The Bear Came Over The Mountain and Away From Her - Essay Sample

Paper Type:  Essay
Pages:  4
Wordcount:  1029 Words
Date:  2023-02-02


There are some similarities in the short story named ''The bear came over the mountain'' BY Munro and the film ''Away from her'' by Egoyan and other authors. This paper analyses the two media and answers several questions on the similarity in the plot and characters that makes the story a success. It evaluates the accuracy of the film to the short story and discusses whether both the film and the short story portrays Alzheimer condition accurately. The paper uses examples either from the conversations or the scenes and episodes in the book and the movie as evidence.

Trust banner

Is your time best spent reading someone else’s essay? Get a 100% original essay FROM A CERTIFIED WRITER!

The short story is a colorful narrative of a relationship between Grant and Fiona, which is affected by an illness that is common in the real world. The film on it is created to bring out the signs and symptoms of Alzheimer, a condition affecting Fiona who is Gant's wife just like in the short story. This is intended to raise its awareness. The film lives up to the criteria and the plot used in the short story. It goes deeper and creates scenes that explain the effects of the condition on both the cognitive functioning and the physical functioning of the affected person vividly.

The plot of the short story is dramatic and educational. Fiona, Grant's wife, becomes sick, and she had to be taken care of in the hospital. Her husband was not permitted to see her. For the first 30 days, she was admitted, Fiona had developed affection to a resident named Aubrey, and she seemed to have forgotten her marriage though they have been married for 45 years. The duration of the union does not stop Fiona from falling in love with a stranger she meets in the hospital. There is devastation, and the relationship is not doing well since the condition of Fiona is worsening. The effects of Alzheimer on the family and social relation is evident in the scene where Grant, Fiona's Husband, tells Marian to move away from the place and move away from her ailing husband, Aubray. According to Grant, this could help calm the situation down by removing Aubary from her sight so that she could forget about him (Egoyan et al., 2006). Marian has no money and must sell the house to afford the expenses of relocation. This is what she refuses. Grant can renew the affection between Aubray and Marian. His wife is, however, not ready to forget the stranger, and this is the exact torture revealed in the film. The memory is slowly fading, and this turns the entire story into a painful account of a life with Alzheimer a condition that affects the mind. According to medical journals. Alzheimer is progressive and affects the brain cells and makes the cells of the brain to wear out. It causes dementia a continued reduced independent thinking and use of skills. It has a significant symptom of Alzheimer in which the person forgets the most recent activities or even events. The reduced memory is evident in several conversations, for instance, the discussion on the color yellow of the flowers and Fiona says that she has forgotten what color yellow represented.

Both the short story and the film clearly explains Alzheimer condition. The conversation between the characters in the movie between the doctor and Fiona reveals a lot of concern on the failing memory. The film is focused on the condition of Fiona's mental health. The directors aim to bring more of Alzheimer into the light. The therapy with the doctor shows a real-time remedy (Egoyan et al., 2006). The doctor form instance asks Fiona what year it if. Her reply is right. When she is asked what she would do if she were in a movie theatre caught up in the fire. Her response is directed to the husband. Fiona asks Grant if they ''nowadays'' go out for movies. How the question is framed, shows are declining memory stability (Munro, 2013). The doctor is testing the semantic memory and the episodic memory in the conversation. Another accurate representation of the mental disorder in the book, as well as the film, is the episode when Fiona and Grant go back home and Fiona is unsure if they moved in the same year or the other year. This is an accurate symptom and an effect of the disorder. It is alarming because according to Grant, they have been staying here since they graduated from university. This is about twenty years ago hence evidence of a declined autobiographical memory the film portrays the new relationship that Fiona gets involved in while in the rehabilitation center to help her from the worsening condition. The particular service center is more highlighted in the film as a place that marks the turning point of her situation. The first thirty days torments her because of the absence of her husband, but over time, she completely forgets all about him and starts finding peace in a new man called Aubrey(Munro, 2013). The short story talks of the relationship as one that started rapidly but did not point out clearly on the effects of the declining autobiographical memory. The film focuses on her declining abilities too. She is no longer doing physical practice built her use of skills is very low. According to the nurse in the film, Fiona was losing her muscles, and soon if she never recovered, she would end up being carried in a walker.


In conclusion, the plot and the characterization of the movie are the same as those in the short story. The focus of the short story is more on the effects of the Alzheimer on the relationships. The Film has the same plot and characterization, although there is variation in the years and some scenes that are added. The film shows more signs of the disorder. It is more focused on the stages and links every behavior that Fiona displays with the declining memory. The film accurately describes the different forms of memory decline: the semantic memory, the autobiographical memory, and even the episodic memory.


Munro, A. (2013, Oct 21). The bear came over the mountain.

The New Yorker. Retrieved from

Cite this page

Similarities in The Bear Came Over The Mountain and Away From Her - Essay Sample. (2023, Feb 02). Retrieved from

Free essays can be submitted by anyone,

so we do not vouch for their quality

Want a quality guarantee?
Order from one of our vetted writers instead

If you are the original author of this essay and no longer wish to have it published on the website, please click below to request its removal:

didn't find image

Liked this essay sample but need an original one?

Hire a professional with VAST experience!

24/7 online support

NO plagiarism